DA Cage Match: Google vs. Jingle

Driving to a meeting yesterday in San Francisco I was informally comparing the results and experience on Google’s DA/voice search platform (1877 Goog 411) and Jingle (1800 Free411). I was trying to reach two Web-based companies, LocalLaunch and Yelp.

Caveats: my testing was in traffic and not controlled/systematic and Google hasn’t acknowledged publicly that they’re doing this.

The results of this limited test were something of a wash. Jingle performed better when it came to finding Yelp but couldn’t find LocalLaunch. Goog411 is more flexible and may have a better database than the one Jingle is using, but its voice recognizers and related technology couldn’t “disambiguate” “Yelp” in a moving car with background noise — nor was it able to on a landline.

In the context of the LocalLaunch search, Goog411 was able to find it without a problem in a moving car, and I was able to connect via voice command. In Jingle’s case the automated front-end didn’t find LocalLaunch, nor was a live agent able to – which implicates the database.

Overall Goog411 was more flexibile, as I said, permitting category search and navigation back and forth from results to details and back. It also allows transmission of numbers via keypad or voice to text on my phone. Jingle says it’s adding category search in Q1. The thing that Jingle had over Goog411 was resort to a live agent, which can be very helpful if the “system” doesn’t understand the query (but only if the database has the information).

Right now there are no ads on Goog411. Jingle has sponsors and advertisers (with offers) who compete with the listing I’m seeking. Jingle has also apparently ceased to connect calls automatically.

I’m going to continue to test these services in real-world situations and report back. I encourage you to do the same. It’s “fun” and free. :)

About these ads

14 Responses to “DA Cage Match: Google vs. Jingle”

  1. eric ng Says:

    Goodbye Jingle! They have no ads and no revenue–Google will kill them!

  2. WW Says:

    Google will dump ads once they find it profitable. Jingle is at least humane enough to offer live operator.

  3. K-Man Says:

    I would like to see Jingle succeed, and I think they will. Does Google have to dive into everything? I have used 1800Free411 a few times and I think the service is good, hey it’s free. I just freak out when I see a mammoth company cornering every market out there.

  4. Royale Says:

    This is typical of Google overexpansion, reaching out in Microsoft-y ways and trying to squash smaller businesses (what was their motto again? “Don’t be evil”?). But as with Microsoft, it won’t work. In fact Jingle does have sponsors and advertisers. Jingle has already grown pretty big recently, and as they grow their database will expand. They’ve already got a great system in place, and live agents. And so they’re miles ahead of everyone else in this game – even Google.

  5. Google Launches Free 411 Service Says:

    [...] in various formats for some time. Steve Poland (a regular contributor here) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

  6. TechCrunch Japanese アーカイブ » Google、無料番号案内の411サービス開始 Says:

    [...] Sterlingが去年書いた関連エントリはココとココ。 Steve [...]

  7. Ajax Girl Says:

    [...] in various formats for some time. Steve Poland (a regular contributor here) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

  8. Techasaur.us Rex - Encyclopedia of Technology News | Yesterday, Today & Tomorrow’s Tech News - » Google Launches Free 411 Service Says:

    [...] in various formats for some time. Steve Poland (a regular contributor here) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

  9. Web Development » Blog Archive » Google Launches Free 411 Service Says:

    [...] in various formats for some time. Steve Poland (a regular contributor here) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

  10. TechCrunch en français » Google lance un service de renseignement téléphonique gratuit Says:

    [...] d’Ouriel: ce produit a été testé en fait par Google depuis un moment comme on peut le lire sur ces billets. Cela remonte a octobre 2006 et cela pourrait faire suite à l’acquisition de 1 877 520 [...]

  11. e5k | 2007 | April | 07 Says:

    [...] d’Ouriel: ce produit a été testé en fait par Google depuis un moment comme on peut le lire sur ces billets. Cela remonte a octobre 2006 et cela pourrait faire suite à l’acquisition de 1 877 520 [...]

  12. ::lemonup:: » Google Launches Free 411 Service Says:

    [...] in various formats for some time. Steve Poland (a regular contributor here) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

  13. Google Launches Free 411 Service at noisylime Says:

    [...] in various formats for some time. Steve Poland (a regular contributor here) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

  14. Google launches Voice Local Search – no reason to call 411 anymore? Says:

    [...] formats for some time. Steve Poland (a judge for the video startups) is pointing me to some posts (and here) by Greg Sterling from last year that discuss this. The earliest reports on this are from [...]

Comments are closed.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 117 other followers

%d bloggers like this: